Are We Overvaluing Employee Satisfaction?

Posted by Mai Hoai Thu on

In this blog post, we will strive to find the answer to the question "Are we overvaluing employee satisfaction?" by investigating whether emphasising workplace contentment actually increases engagement and productivity and examining its effects on key metrics, such as eNPS, absenteeism, and turnover rates.

Read more: Are You One of These Four Employees Who Make or Break a Meeting? 

Are We Overvaluing Employee Satisfaction?

Table of contents

What Is Employee Satisfaction?

Employee satisfaction refers to the level of contentment and motivation an employee experiences in their workplace. It is influenced by a variety of external factors such as salary, benefits, working conditions, and opportunities for professional growth.

When employees feel valued and supported, their motivation rises, leading to higher levels of engagement, productivity, and overall satisfaction.

Read more: Want to Empower Your Employees Even More? Be Lazy!

Back to the top

Why Employee Satisfaction Matters? 

Employee satisfaction is not just a feel-good factor but a vital component of a successful business strategy. Companies with high employee satisfaction ratings often outperform their competitors. Studies have demonstrated that satisfied employees are more productive, engaged, and likely to stay with their organisation.

This association between employee satisfaction and business success is no coincidence. Organisations prioritising employee well-being are better positioned to achieve their goals, innovate, and maintain a competitive advantage in their industry.

Read more: Giving Performance Reviews to Your Most Difficult Employees 

Back to the top

Which Employee Satisfaction Metrics Are Important?

1. Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS)

One of the most widely used metrics to measure employee satisfaction is the Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS). This scoring system helps employers gauge employee sentiment and loyalty by asking one key question: “On a scale from 1-10, how likely are you to recommend this organisation as a place to work?” Based on their responses, employees are categorised as:

  • Promoters (scores 9-10): Loyal enthusiasts who will advocate for your organisation.
  • Passives (scores 7-8): Satisfied but unenthusiastic employees who might be easily swayed by competitors.
  • Detractors (scores 0-6): Unhappy employees who can tarnish your organisation's reputation.

To calculate your eNPS, subtract the percentage of detractors from the percentage of promoters:

eNPS = % of Promoters – % of Detractors

This straightforward calculation gives organisations insight into employee loyalty and satisfaction.

2. Absenteeism Rate

When people miss work or school when they should be, it is known as absenteeism. The company certainly will suffer financial losses if the absenteeism rate is high.

High absenteeism rates can indicate numerous issues within the business, including poor leadership, a lack of work-life balance, or mental health challenges. Moreover, absenteeism often correlates with low employee satisfaction. Increased absenteeism can lead to higher workloads and stress, perpetuating a cycle of dissatisfaction.

To calculate absenteeism, divide the number of absence days by the total number of available workdays during a specific period.

Absenteeism = absence days / total number of available workdays

Read more: The Urgent Need for a Leadership Development Plan

3. Turnover Rate

The so-called ‘Great Resignation’ has highlighted the importance of employee satisfaction like never before. According to the Achievers Workforce Institute’s Employee Engagement & Retention Report, 52% of North American workers intended to seek new employment in 2021. Higher employee satisfaction directly correlates with lower turnover rates, which represent significant costs for organizations and disruptions in productivity.

To calculate turnover, identify the number of employee departures during a specified time frame and divide it by the number of employees at the beginning of that period.

Turnover = number of employee departures / number of employees at the beginning

Read more: Why Do Your Employees Quit? 5 Typical Causes of High Turnover Rate

4. Employee Satisfaction Index (ESI)

The Employee Satisfaction Index (ESI) offers a broader view of employee sentiment, integrating aspects of expectations and enthusiasm. ESI surveys typically assess satisfaction in areas such as job fulfillment, alignment with personal expectations, and proximity to an ideal work environment.

To calculate ESI, use the following formula:

ESI = [mean value of responses/3] x 100

Back to the top

How to Measure Employee Satisfaction

Measuring employee satisfaction is crucial for fostering a positive workplace culture. While the specific methods may vary depending on the unique needs of each business, the overall approach remains consistent.

Here is a streamlined process to effectively gauge employee satisfaction:

  • Define Objectives and Metrics: Clearly identify the specific aspects of employee satisfaction you wish to measure, such as engagement, morale, or work-life balance.
  • Select Measurement Methods: Choose appropriate methods for gathering feedback, such as anonymous surveys, one-on-one meetings, suggestion boxes, or focus groups.
  • Design and Administer: Develop well-structured surveys or assessment tools tailored to your objectives, ensuring they are distributed effectively to reach all employees.
  • Analyse and Interpret Data: Systematically review the collected data to uncover trends, insights, and overall satisfaction levels, using both quantitative and qualitative analysis where applicable.
  • Identify Key Drivers: Investigate the factors that have the most significant impact on employee satisfaction, such as management practices, workplace environment, or opportunities for growth.

By following these steps, businesses can gain meaningful insights into employee satisfaction and create a more engaged and motivated workforce.

Read more: How Quiet Managing Nurtures Greatness from the Shadows 

Back to the top

When is the Best Time to Assess Employee Satisfaction?

The timing of employee satisfaction assessments can significantly impact the quality of the responses. Consider conducting surveys after significant organisational changes, during performance review periods, or at regular intervals (e.g., annually or bi-annually).

This ensures that employees provide feedback based on their most recent experiences and perceptions.

Back to the top

When is the Best Time to Assess Employee Satisfaction?

How to Improve Employee Satisfaction

Boosting employee satisfaction can lead to enhanced engagement and productivity. Here are several strategies organisations can implement:

  • Enhance Communication: Establish an intranet platform to improve internal communication and collaboration, keep everyone updated with the the news or other activities.
  • Recognition Programs: Implement reward systems and recognition programs to celebrate employee achievements.
  • External Factors: Revise your compensation structure, improve employee benefits, and create a comfortable working environment, especially for women after maternity leave to help them have more time to adapt to work and spend time for her newborns.
  • Career Development: Develop clear career pathways and strategies for employee development to give staff a sense of purpose and direction.

Read more: Are your organisational stars hard to satisfy?

Back to the top

Is It Always Good to Prioritise Employee Satisfaction?

The straightforward answer is no. Like many facets of organizational dynamics, employee satisfaction has its complexities. Over-emphasising satisfaction can lead to a lot of unintended issues, including:

  • Decreased productivity and efficiency: When employees prioritise personal comfort over performance, it leads to decline in overall productivity and efficiency, ultimately hindering the organisational goals.
  • Lack of accountability and responsibility: A culture focused on making employees feel good may weaken the accountability as employees might less inclined to take ownership of their roles and responsibility.
  • Unfair treatment and resentment among employees: What satisfies one employee may not satisfy others, undermining collaboration and unity.
  • Potential for complacency and lack of innovation: When employees become too comfortable, they may resist change and new ideas that are crucial for growth.

Read more: What Are the Available Tools to Identify High-Potential Employees?

Back to the top

The Balancing Act of Employee Satisfaction

Employee satisfaction is undoubtedly a critical component of a successful organisation, organizations will foster a resilient, motivated workforce ready to drive the company towards success. By measuring, understanding, and improving employee satisfaction, businesses set themselves up for long-term success.

However, balance is the key. Over-prioritising employee satisfaction can create significant challenges, as outlines above. It should be a part of a broader approach that also considers business objectives, performance and the diverse need of employee.

Back to the top

Download GPI brochure | Talent management

Topics: Talent Management

Upcoming TRG Events

Latest Posts

Most Viewed Posts

Our Editorial Mission

Rick Yvanovich

 Rick Yvanovich
 /Founder & CEO/

With TRG International Blog, it is our mission to be your preferred partner providing solutions that work and we will make sure to guide your business to greatness every day.

Subscribe to TRG Blog

Follow TRG Blog